The most effective street journeys in America is the Miami to Key West drive. As you’re touring alongside Freeway 1, you’ll drive proper by way of Islamorada. Irrespective of in case you keep the night time or not, plan on having a meal at among the finest eating places in Islamorada at the least. 

There are such a lot of issues to do in Islamorada that you simply received’t wish to go away. It’s our favourite place within the Florida Keys. There are water actions, seashores, museums, state parks, and there are some actually good eating places in Islamorada.

Islamorada has a plethora of eateries, together with steak homes, cafes, bars, breweries, and diners. It’s exhausting to depart Islamorada with out consuming seafood, however there are many different dishes.

With so many eating places, it may well really feel formidable to determine the place to eat. Don’t fear. We’ve obtained you coated. Take a look at these 17 finest eating places in Islamorada.

1. Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar

Lorelei’s is without doubt one of the most well-known and finest eating places in Islamorada. Within the morning, native fishermen frequent it for an early morning breakfast. The group adjustments at lunch and dinner, with islanders and vacationers coming for a meal.

Many are drawn to this prime restaurant due to its waterfront location and sundown views. Nightly dwell music makes this a well-liked and vibrant Islamorada restaurant. That is our go-to spot for sundown in Islamorada.

Lorelei’s is seafood heaven, serving up all of the Florida Keys favorites. Attempt the Sundown Conch Fritters, Key’s Conch Chowder, Stone Crab Chowder, and extra. There’s additionally a Little Mates & Mermaids menu, excellent for kids. Their hottest menu merchandise is the World Well-known Fish Sandwich. Different choices in addition to fish embrace burgers, rooster, and steak. – View menu 

2. Chef Michael’s

Chef Michael’s is without doubt one of the finest fine-dining eating places in Islamorada. Its elegant eating is juxtaposed with a relaxed island environment. It’s the excellent restaurant for a celebration, perhaps an anniversary or a birthday.

The menu options trendy New American dishes that target showcasing native produce. The chef-owner began cooking in New York’s finest eating places earlier than heading to the Caribbean. He has now mastered the artwork of great seafood cooking.

Are you eager for a mouth-watering seafood delight? You then’ve obtained to order one of many recent catches of the day. Mahi Mahi, Yellowtail Snapper, and Hogfish steadily characteristic on the menu. Chef Michael’s meals seems to be pretty much as good because it tastes. He has an impeccable eye for element. – View menu 

3. Sq. Grouper

Sq. Grouper is a comparatively new addition to Islamorada’s restaurant scene. They serve up New American delicacies in a standard bar and grill setting. This is without doubt one of the finest eating places in Islamorada for satisfying your tastebuds. It’s additionally a incredible place to eat in case you’re wanting cocktails.

Their home specialties embrace the Sq. Grouper Seafood Stew and the Truffled Lobster Mac. Get pleasure from this contemporary delicacies both indoors or on their outside patio. That is quick changing into among the finest eating places in Islamorada. – View menu 

4. Morada Bay Seaside Cafe

The Morada Bay Seaside Café overlooks the Florida Bay. It’s excellent for sitting proper on the seashore together with your toes within the sand. It is a true Islamorada joint, it’s laidback and tremendous pleasant. You simply can’t beat this Islamorada restaurant for its unparalleled seashore and ocean views.

Why not attempt the Island Cobb Salad or the Fried Rooster Sando Island Model? In fact, their catch of the day and Mahi Mahi Tacos are at all times widespread. Additionally they have non-fish dishes, together with the Turkey Membership, Past Burger, and Steak. – View menu 

5. Inexperienced Turtle Inn Restaurant

The Inexperienced Turtle is a prime restaurant in Islamorada. They delight themselves on their relaxed ambiance and gourmand flavors. The Inexperienced Turtle serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner. For the finest breakfast in Islamorada, take a look at the Inexperienced Turtle.

Their breakfast menu is in depth, with a bunch of further sides and pastries. You can attempt the Lobster Benedict for some early morning seafood. They’ve obtained waffles, pancakes, and breakfast burritos. You identify it. They’ve most likely obtained it on the menu.

The Inexperienced Turtle Inn was the one constructing to outlive the 1935 hurricane utterly. This restaurant is just a little slice of Florida Keys historical past. The inside is full of historic pictures documenting Islamorada life. There’s a well-recognized homely vibe to this institution. – View menu 

6. Ziggie & Mad Canine’s

Not solely is Ziggie & Mad Canine’s restaurant top-rated, however it’s additionally a slice of Islamorada historical past. This historic constructing dates all the way in which again to the Nineteen Thirties. Ziggie & Mad Canine’s has a sports activities bar really feel to it. There’s at all times a superb environment, and it’s a premier place to get a past juicy steak.

Ziggie & Mad Canine’s has an eclectic menu. You identify it, they’ve obtained it. There’s one thing for the entire household. There’s duck breast, pork chops, burgers, steak, scallops, and pasta. – View menu 

7. Pierre’s

Pierre’s units a particularly excessive bar for superb eating. It’s among the finest superb eating eating places within the Florida Keys. That is the best restaurant for a date night time or a celebratory night. Pierre’s has an intimate environment in addition to romantic sundown views.

Pierre’s describes their meals as French fusion with an area twist. Standard dishes at Pierre’s embrace the seared scallops, the rack of lamb, and octopus.

Hidden downstairs at Pierre’s is the Inexperienced Flash Lounge. The right area for an after-dinner drink and dancing on Friday and Saturday nights.

8. Ciao Hound

When pondering of Islamorada, Italian meals doesn’t immediately come to thoughts. Ciao Hound is without doubt one of the finest locations to eat in case you’re in search of one of the best Italian in Islamorada. Ciao Hound is a family-friendly restaurant with lovely decor and outside patio seating.

They serve each breakfast and dinner and have an intensive wine record. As an Italian joint, you possibly can’t go improper with their pasta dishes. Their Lasagna Bolognese is wealthy and moreish, and the Caprese Ravioli is tremendous creamy. – View menu 

9. Islamorada Fish Firm

The Islamorada Fish Firm is without doubt one of the finest waterfront eating places on the island. Chill out at this restaurant for lunch or dinner because the solar units. It’s a really perfect location, and the meals is fairly good, too. The clue is within the identify: This restaurant focuses on recent seafood.

There’s a uncooked bar that features oysters, shrimp, and the legendary stone crab claw. You may’t go improper in case you order the Mahi or shrimp tacos, crab desserts, Yellowtail Snapper, or the native catch. Additionally accessible is a “you catch, we cook dinner” choice, excellent for these fishing in Islamorada.

Even the only of dishes, like fish & chips, is an actual crowd pleaser. Be warned, in case you don’t like fish, there aren’t many selections. Come on, what had been you anticipating from the Islamorada Fish Firm? The Bacon Cheeseburger and Jerk Rooster Sandwich are a few of your solely choices. – View menu 

10. Bayside Connoisseur

Bayside is one other widespread native restaurant serving up top-quality Italian meals. In the event you’re craving pizza, Bayside Connoisseur has obtained you coated. They’ve the whole lot you can probably need on a pizza. There’s the Ricotta, Hawaiian, the Veggie Delight, Meat Lovers, and Quarto Formaggio, simply to call just a few. You may even add mouth-watering do-it-yourself meatballs on prime of your pizza!

Except for pizza, there may be soup, salad, tons of fantastic pasta dishes, and gourmand sandwiches. Their Grouper Reuben, Traditional Cuban Press, and Spicy Fish Taco are three widespread Connoisseur specialties. – View menu 

11. Mangrove Mike’s Cafe

Mangrove Mike’s is the place to go for a few of the finest breakfast in Islamorada. Additionally they serve an unimaginable lunch that’s tremendous filling. Their menu is in depth, with one thing for everybody at Mangrove Mike’s.

A few of the hottest menu objects embrace the seasoned flour tortilla wraps. They’ve nearly each filling possible, together with rooster, tuna, turkey, vegetarian, and shrimp. A few of their specials embrace the Burrito Supreme and Fish Sandwich.

Mangrove Mike’s informal environment makes this a well-liked vacationer and native hang-out. In the event you’re a canine proprietor, you’ll be happy to listen to they’re a pet-friendly institution. – View menu 

12. Lazy Days

Lazy Days restaurant is located on the Atlantic Ocean facet of Islamorada. This waterfront restaurant is good for peace, quiet, and good views while you eat. Sit at a beachside desk or up on the second-level terrace. There’ll at all times be good views of paradise!

One of many issues Lazy Days is understood for is their “cook dinner your catch.” First, you select the way you need your fish ready: grilled, fried, blackened, or broiled. Then, sit again and luxuriate in certainly one of their specialty tropical drinks. Make certain to attempt the Florida Lobster in case you’re visiting in the course of the lobster season within the Florida Keys. We additionally actually just like the Cracked Conch, Yellowtail Snapper, and Grouper they won’t disappoint. – View menu 

13. Islamorada Shrimp Shack

The proprietor of Shrimp Shack was wanting round for cuisines that weren’t being served in Islamorada. She determined to give attention to the Key West Pink Shrimp. This is without doubt one of the finest Islamorada eating places to seize your self some delectable pink juicy shrimp. It wasn’t lengthy after re-opening that the Shrimp Shack was featured on Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives.

Tuck into their Well-known Shrimp Fritters or the Bacon Wrapped Shrimp. Shrimp lovers shall be visiting time and time once more. In addition to shrimp, there’s conch, calamari, and alligator, in addition to rooster and pork tacos. – View menu 

14. Island Grill

Don’t be fooled by the Island Grill’s shack-like exterior. This is without doubt one of the prime eating places in Islamorada. Island Grill’s menu is numerous, and there are simply too many tempting dishes. They’ve completely the whole lot you can probably need.

There are shrimp tacos, burgers, seafood pasta, sandwiches, and freshly caught fish. In fact, you should go away room for dessert. An compulsory slice of Key Lime Pie, or perhaps fried cheesecake or chocolate brownie.

Along with scrumptious meals, they’ve an intensive beer, wine, and cocktail record. Attempt their Grapefruit Watermelon Cooler cocktail or a frozen Strawberry Daiquiri. – View menu 

15. Hungry Tarpon – Robbie’s Marina

The Hungry Tarpon is a superb waterfront restaurant in Islamorada. You’ll have heard of the favored Islamorada exercise of feeding the tarpons. Effectively, the Hungry Tarpon is situated at Robbie’s, a marina, boat rental, and restaurant space.

For a few {dollars}, you possibly can feed the tarpons. Dangle meals over the deck, and the tarpon jumps up, supplying you with a sandpapery kiss. Simply throughout from this widespread Islamorada attraction is Hungry Tarpon. Eat a scrumptious meal whereas watching the vacationers feed the fish.

Seafood is the specialty of Hungry Tarpon. The most effective issues about Hungry Tarpon is you can carry your personal catch. They’ll cook dinner it the way you need, and also you simply select the edges and calm down. That is additionally an amazing place to attempt a few of Islamorada’s best-known meals. The Conch Chowder and Florida Keys Stone Crab Claws are heavenly. – View menu 

16. Kaiyo Grill & Sushi Bar

Calling all sushi lovers, Kaiyo Grill & Sushi Bar is one of the best restaurant in Islamorada for sushi! This acclaimed mix of Asian delicacies nonetheless serves Islamorada seafood, however an Asian twist makes it distinctive.

They’ve obtained Vietnamese Meatballs, fried rice, Tempura Fish Bites, steaks, and freshly caught fish. Head over to the sushi menu, and you’ll not be upset. They’ve their very own specialty rolls, together with the Islamorada (tuna, avo, mango, and cilantro). They’ve sushi platters to share, nigiri, and sashimi. That is severely a sushi fanatic’s dream restaurant. – View menu 

17. Marker 88 Restaurant

Marker 88 serves lunch, dinner, and brunch on the weekend. This native restaurant is situated proper on the waterfront in essentially the most idyllic of settings. Get pleasure from meals and drinks on the tiki bar overlooking the water whereas watching the sundown.

The menu at Marker 88 largely focuses on what Islamorada does finest…seafood! For appetizers, the Sizzling Blue Crab Dip or the Coconut Shrimp are scrumptious choices. Don’t skip dessert. Their Key Lime Pie is a much less conventional meringue-topped pie. Chocolate lovers will devour the Molten Chocolate Cake. – View menu 

What Meals is Islamorada Identified For?

Islamorada is a part of the Florida Keys. Subsequently, with out hesitation, among the finest and most well-known meals is Key Lime Pie. This beloved tangy dessert will be eaten at almost each restaurant in Islamorada.

One other prime meals to eat in Islamorada is stone crab claws. Crab season is between October and Might; in case you’re in Islamorada, don’t miss out. Seafood, usually, is without doubt one of the finest issues to eat in Islamorada. Not solely is there an abundance of seafood eating places, however their catches are at all times recent. Uncover one of the best eating places in Islamorada for these widespread meals favorites.

The place are your Islamorada eating places?

We’re at all times in search of one of the best eating places in Islamorada to check out!